Product Ratings & Reviews
Product Reviews
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Pottery Barn Kids.
Pumpkin Treat Bag
Made of soft felt and lined with percale, our pumpkin treat bag will delight your little trick-or-treater with its big jack-o-lantern smile and pick-stitch detailing. 9" diameter, 13.5" high Woven of soft felt and lined with a cotton blend. Features decorative stitching and a jack-o-lantern face. Arched handle and puffy polyester batting makes this treat bag comfortable for carrying. Coordinates with all of our spooky costumes. Personalization appears centered, on the back of the treat bag. Imported.
Average Customer Rating
56
reviews
(42 out of 56 reviewers recommend this product to a friend)
Sort by:
Customer Reviews
Review 1 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
Lava
Recommend:No
Very Disappointed!
November 13, 2012
I was very disappointed after getting this treat bag in the mail. Where has the Pottery Barn quality gone? This bag is mad of a very thin felt material that came squished and wrinkled in a bag and cannot stand on its own. I have a friend who purchased these treat bags only a few years ago and they were way different. I'd return it if I could!
Share this review:
Review 2 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
Anonymous
,San Antonio
,tx
Age:35-44
Number of Children:4
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:8+
Recommend:Yes
4th pumpkin bag in 10 years
October 29, 2012
This bag might be a hair smaller than my original bags! 10 years ago I ordered one for my daughter (monogrammed) and I loved it! 7 years ago I came back and ordered another for my next daughter and to my surprise it still matched perfect even the monogramming? This year I came back and was so excited to see they still had them! I ordered 2 for my new baby boys, they are a tad smaller not as thick and the monogramming is smaller but not too small, it also looks to be the same font! It is missing the black stitching around the handle and also on the sides around the pumpkin face (I might add the stitching myself just because I like all their stuff to match). I stuffed them to get out the wrinkles and I am happy with them! Not as great as before but still acceptable! Thanks
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 3 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
wvmommy
,Danville
,Wv
Age:25-34
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:3
Recommend:Yes
Pumpkin treat bag.
October 29, 2012
This is a super cute bag, perfect for younger trick or treaters.
Share this review:
Review 4 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
MiamiGirl
,Miami
,Fl
Age:35-44
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:4
Recommend:No
Disappointed
October 16, 2012
Bought for my 4 year olds first Halloween 4 years ago & was excited to buy for my newborn's first Halloween this year. I was really disappointed in the difference in the quality of the product in the four years. There is much less detailed stitching & my newborns name is so much smaller, then on my 4 year olds. Not happy with changes on product!
4 of 4 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 5 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
mommy2boysCA
,CA
Age:25-34
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:4
Recommend:Yes
Does not look like the picture!
October 1, 2012
I wish I would have read these reviews before buying this bag. If it really looked liked it does in the catalog, it would be soooo cute. But it is flattened, squished and wrinkled, and nothing you can do will fix it. It honestly looks like it was crumpled in a ball and thrown in the trash. What a disappointment. :(
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 6 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
Anonymous
,Cedar Grove
,NJ
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:2
Oldest Child:2
Recommend:No
Junk!
September 22, 2012
I buy PB kids all the time. This is by far the junkiest thing I've ever bought. It came a wrinkled mess that can not be steamed or ironed. I returned to the store and all the ones in the store looked the same way. Super disappointed!!
5 of 5 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 7 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
Mom2Ced
Recommend:No
So Dissapointed! tiny print, cheap!!
September 12, 2012
I ordered this for my daughter in 07, I now have a newborn son and wanted him to have the same thing. I ordered this and received it and its not worth $5.00!! Its so cheap now, as if its from a dollar store! My mother in law does monogramming so I can get stuff monogrammed for free but paid $7.00 to have it done because I wanted it exactly the same, my sons name is soooo tiny, you can hardly see it!! I could have bought two "quality" bags somewhere and had their names put on it for way cheaper. NOT worth the money. Sad Sad for pottery barn . Im returning it!
5 of 5 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 8 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
JudiAU
Recommend:No
Disappointing
September 4, 2012
I was going to order this treat bag online and I am so glad I stopped by the store today. This whole line was so cheap looking that I would have been furious if they had arrived in the mail. Super cheap "fabric" that looks like interface lining. It looks nothing like quality felt. The stitching and decoration were fine but I couldn't get past the cheap-o looking materials.
5 of 5 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 9 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
jaboliver
Recommend:Yes
Pumpkin Treat Bag
October 21, 2011
The bag is very cute but the monogramming is very disappointing. You can barely see the name, it is very small. I expected it to be a little bigger. I would recommend the bag to someone but not the $7 monogramming. Save you MONEY on that part!!!! :)
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 10 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
Mommyof3texans
,Dallas
,Tx
Age:25-34
Number of Children:3
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:7
Recommend:Yes
BIG DIFFERENCES
October 12, 2011
I also ordered the same pumpkin treat bag in back in 2008, and there is a huge difference in quality! Yes, my daughters stitching was about 2x's larger and the bag was so much bigger. This year's bag lacks the cute black stitching around the face and handle that the old one had. Since, I wanted them to match, I will have to personally add that.
4 of 4 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 11 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
LeslieSD
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:2
Oldest Child:5
Recommend:Yes
Cute
October 6, 2011
Super cute and I love the ability to personalize them for both my kids. Like other reviews said one of the 2 bags I ordered had the personalization not straight. I called customer service and was sent a new bag, no problem! I love that it collapses for storage reasons but they puff back up for use and they are plenty big.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 12 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
NorthCarolinaMom
,Charlotte
,NC
Age:25-34
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:5
Recommend:No
Poor Quality
October 6, 2011
I ordered the same (or what I thought was the same) Pumpkin Treat Bag in 2008 and could not believe the difference in quality with the Pumpkin Treat Bag I received this week. The bag is much smaller and of much poorer quality. Looks like Pottery Barn Kids was trying to save money and switched vendors for a bag that cost them less to make. The monogramming is awful as well. The name on the bag I ordered in 2008 is 2x bigger than the name I had monogrammed recently. Half the amount of thread was used and the stitching is not smooth. I have been a long-time customer of PBK and can't believe the difference in quality that a few years makes on the same item.
8 of 8 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 13 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
MorganB
Recommend:Yes
Pumpkin Treat Bag Monogram
October 1, 2011
The pumpkin itself is cute. Based on the other reviews, I was prepared for it to not hold it's shape well. I am fine with that because I did want a soft treat bag. I am, however, dissappointed in the monogram size. There is a ton of room for a large monogram on the back of the pumpkin, but it is very small. I wish I would have not paid Pottery Barn to do it and taken it to a local store to get it a better looking size. It is barely noticed on the back at all. I gave an average rating, because to me monogramming is what makes the product.
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 14 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
AbqMomma
,Albuquerque
,NM
Age:25-34
Number of Children:3
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:4
Recommend:Yes
Great Bag! Lasts!
September 27, 2011
I first purchased this bag in 2007 when my first son was born. He has been using it every Halloween since. It has held up amazingly. So great, in fact, I purchased another for my daughter in 2009 for her first Halloween. And another just this month for the newest baby. I have had no issues. I love the quality and the construction. The personalization on our bags are perfect. You can't please everyone. But for me and for trick or treating this bag is perfect :)
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 15 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
egmom
,Elk Grove
,ca
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:1 & under
Recommend:No
Not the greatest
August 25, 2011
As others mentioned, this bag arrived today flat and very wrinkled. My son's name that I had personalized on it was stitched crooked. There is no black stitching around the bag like in the picture . Definitely not the quality I was expecting from Pottery Barn, too bad. :(
1 of 2 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 16 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
MominHouston
,Houston
,TX
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:2
Oldest Child:2
Recommend:Yes
Picture is misleading
August 24, 2011
Like other comments mention, the picture is quite misleading. There is no stiching on the bag or on the handle. That said, I expected this and the bag is still a really cute product that I'm certain will get years of use in our house.
Share this review:
Review 17 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
gwildcats
,Kansas City
,KS
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:1 & under
Recommend:Yes
A little wrinkly, but cute.
August 11, 2011
As the other reviewers have stated, this treat bag arrives flat and very wrinkled. I immediately removed it from the packing bag and stuffed it with paper to give it a shape and push out some of the wrinkles. That seems to have helped a little. Besides this issue, this is a really cute bag. I would recommended getting it personalized because it just adds to bag.
Share this review:
Review 18 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
DOMSmom1069
,Bethlehem
,PA
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:1 & under
Recommend:No
Not as Pictured
August 4, 2011
I previously purchased the bunny and chick Easter Treat Bags and loved the quality of them. I was expecting the same quality in the Pumpkin Treat Bag, but it is nowhere near as nice as the Easter Treat Bags. It did not even look like the picture on the website, the black stitching around the face and on the handle is not even there...this happened on the original and the replacement I received today.
4 of 4 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 19 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
crcII
,TX
Age:25-34
Number of Children:2
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:4
Recommend:Yes
Great Holiday Necessity
November 1, 2010
My 4 year old boy and 1 year old baby girl both loved their Pumpkin treat bags. Having their names on them is great so we haven't had any disputes over goodies! We will definitely get years worth of fun from this product.
Share this review:
Review 20 for Pumpkin Treat Bag
FunMomma
,Nashville, TN
Age:25-34
Number of Children:1
Youngest Child:1 & under
Oldest Child:1 & under
Recommend:No
Terrible quality
October 16, 2010
This arrived mashed/flattened. Poor quality. Bag itself is crooked and so is the monogram. Looks & feels cheap. The orange color is not very pretty either. I have already returned this. Very disappointed b/c Pottery Barn items are usually so wonderful!
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
